In The News

Back to all news

Penfield student dead after being struck by a car in Rochester, driver charged with DWAI

As Featured On:

PENFIELD, N.Y. (WROC) — An 11th grade student at Penfield High School was pronounced dead Sunday after being struck by a vehicle while crossing Chestnut Street with his father just after 12 a.m. Saturday.

The student, identified as 16-year-old Matthew Bittner was 16-years-old, succumbed to his injuries Sunday morning, Rochester police officials said.

Rochester police officials say the 39-year-old driver of the vehicle remained at the scene and cooperated with the investigation. They say the driver said he did not see Bittner crossing the road due to heavy rainfall, and swerved in an unsuccessful attempt to avoid him.

The driver was ultimately charged with third degree aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle, and DWAI (marijuana).

Attorney Peter Pullano with Tully Rinckey says DWAI’s are not as common as DWI’s. But he’s predicting that will change, now that marijuana is legal in the state.

“We’re going to see more of them now that marijuana is legal. They’ve always been there, they’re not as common place as DWI of course,” he said.

Rochester Police say the recent legalization is a concern for them. A spokesperson for the department tells News 8 it requires additional training to properly detect this impairment; the highest level requiring several years of experience.

The department says in general, people sometimes rationalize their actions by using the argument, “Well, I’m not drunk.” But according to the law — DWIs and DWAI’s are the same level of offense.

“It’s Class A misdemeanor, it could involve a year in jail, it could involve three years probation,” said Pullano.

Pullano says for this case, prosecution will have to prove whether impairment directly caused the fatality.

“Just because a person is impaired and there is a fatality, doesn’t necessarily mean the person is guilty of a homicide, manslaughter, even murder arguably, that’s a question has to be fleshed out by a jury. Did the impairment cause the death or were there other factors?”

Pullano says there’s not a lot we can infer from the first charge: why the driver was allegedly operating an unlicensed vehicle, and why it’s considered aggravated, remains unknown

The driver was issued an appearance ticket to appear in Rochester City Court at a later date.

Officials say the case is now being investigated by the Major crimes Unit, who will work in concert with the Monroe County District Attorney’s office to determine if any additional charges are applicable.

Read More

Featured Attorney

Recent Posts

You can contact us 24 hours a day, 7 days a week via phone at 8885294543, by e-mail at or by clicking the button below:

Ready to book your consultation? Click below to pay our consultation fee and book your meeting with an attorney today!

Contact us today to schedule your consultation.

Get Started